Forums » Elder Scrolls

Skyrim: What City Do You Hate the Most?

    • Moderator
    • 724 posts
    December 4, 2017 11:37 AM EST

    Out of all the nine holds in Skyrim, which city would you say you hate the most? I would have to go with Winterhold. A city that no longer posses its former glory, the only thing it literally has going for it is the College. It has 10 fully done buildings at best, the climate is fucking terrible, and the Jarl is really forgettable. I disdain every quest that has me go there (which thankfully isn't too many). 

    Rant over, your turn.

    • 32 posts
    December 4, 2017 12:02 PM EST
    Markarth....I really don’t know why. I don’t like getting sucked into all the quests at the entrance with the reachmen, cidna mine, molag bal. It is also really far out of the way for any playthrough a focusing on more central cities which means I was likely sent out here for some annoying radiant quest. I also feel that many people either love the dwemer or hate them and thus either love or hate markarth. Personally I am not a big fan of the dwemer architecture and this much prefer a Wildhelm or Whiterun aesthetically.
  • Meh
    • 112 posts
    December 4, 2017 1:02 PM EST

    Winterhold and Morthal. I felt like these places were a let down especially after reading what there were supposed to be like in Lore and such.

    • 503 posts
    December 4, 2017 1:43 PM EST

    Falkreath. Just feels a bit naff really. There's not anything massively interesting going on, the surrounding woodland is nice but not necesarrily unique and the fact that it's in the south doesn't do it any favours. It just feels kinda forgotten really. It's a shame Helgen had to be destroyed because that would make it far more interesting, the relationship between the two and stuff like that.

    • 441 posts
    December 4, 2017 1:51 PM EST
    Windhelm for me. It is a pretty depressing city. The Nords harrassing that woman. Children trying to get people assassinated. Jack the Ripper. Oppressive stone walls. Oppressive snow.
    • 611 posts
    December 4, 2017 2:17 PM EST

    Winterhold. Doubly so with Frostfall. If the cold doesn't kill you, the bears will. Or maybe the ice wolves. Or! Maybe the sudden drops around the city's edge. Or you could let the Jarl bore you to death with his boohooing about the mages and his poor city that he's clearly making no efforts to rebuild. 

    • 73 posts
    December 4, 2017 3:08 PM EST

    Yep Winterhold.  I kinda wish it was just a complete ghost town except for the college.  Maybe leave one beggar who squats in the ruins of the Jarl's house and claims he's the Jarl, and a horker.  Just feel that if it's supposed to be a ruined town then go all out, make it a sprawling ruin that's haunted by wolves and maybe worse with the college looming over it all to the north.

    • 698 posts
    December 4, 2017 4:46 PM EST

    Well, most of them don't really feel like cities at all, which is part of the problem.

    Winterhold? Yeah, would probably be better as an uninhabited ghost town rather than a Jarl's Hall, Inn and, like, two houses. Sorry, but its barely even a village.

    Dawnstar isn't a whole lot better, but Falkreath at least has that gloomy atmosphere, with the graveyard and such.

     

    • 444 posts
    December 4, 2017 4:59 PM EST

    Markarth.

    I hate surprises and betrayal, and I got freaking bushwhacked when I got there: betrayed by the guards and tossed into Cidhna Mines because of some forsworn drama that, to this day, I still don't fully understand... look man... I'm too pretty to survive in jail xD

    Then the whole Abandoned House ordeal. One minute I'm helping a vigilant put down a supernatural threat in the house, then Molag Bal shows up and this guy I'm assisting tries to end me. Now I've got to kill some guy I initially tried to help, all because Molag Bal has decided to flex his muscles a bit.

    Nope. I was ready to dust my feet off that whole town and let it all burn in the flames of Oblivion xD

    • 155 posts
    December 4, 2017 5:02 PM EST

    Hard choice between Riften and Markarth. I'd say I hate Riften more because at least Markarth has the best bard in the game. Both are so corrupted that you can just shoot your bow anywhere and you're guaranteed to hit a criminal.

    I enjoy every other city except Windhelm and I still like it after I conquer it for the Imperials.


    This post was edited by Ebonslayer at December 4, 2017 5:13 PM EST
    • 611 posts
    December 4, 2017 5:02 PM EST

    ShinJin said:

    Markarth.

    I hate surprises and betrayal, and I got freaking bushwhacked when I got there: betrayed by the guards and tossed into Cidhna Mines because of some forsworn drama that, to this day, I still don't fully understand... look man... I'm too pretty to survive in jail xD

    Then the whole Abandoned House ordeal. One minute I'm helping a vigilant put down a supernatural threat in the house, then Molag Bal shows up and this guy I'm assisting tries to end me. Now I've got to kill some guy I initially tried to help, all because Molag Bal has decided to flex his muscles a bit.

    Nope. I was ready to dust my feet off that whole town and let it all burn in the flames of Oblivion xD

    These are all really good points. Winterhold may be a shanty town in the middle of nowhere, but in Markarth, things go from bad to worse in a hurry. 

    • 216 posts
    December 4, 2017 5:39 PM EST

    I can't hate on Winterhold, because I adore snow, but I agree with you that they should have went with the Ghost Town. If only cities were as good as Oblivion.

    • 444 posts
    December 5, 2017 11:46 AM EST

    BTW, this thread has graced the TV Twitter page ;D

    • Moderator
    • 724 posts
    December 5, 2017 11:51 AM EST

    ShinJin said:

    BTW, this thread has graced the TV Twitter page ;D

    Awesome to hear! Really interesting answers from everyone. And I thought I was the only one who despised Markarth :p


    This post was edited by Rogue at December 5, 2017 11:52 AM EST
    • 503 posts
    December 5, 2017 1:38 PM EST

    Did not see the amount of attention Markarth is getting coming, I thought everyone loved massive Dwarven stuff?! I guess I kinda like the corruption and the whole Forsworn deal, it gives the city more depth than the others, and although the city is filled with people you wouldn't want to meet in an alley at night, I think its awesome in it's broken kinda way.

    • 9 posts
    December 6, 2017 12:12 AM EST

    Dang, definitely surprised with how many people hate Markarth. I absolutely love the city style and I think the whole corruptness forsworn business adds a lot of character.

    My least favorite city of Skyrim would probably have to be Winterhold. While I hate to be part of the Winterhold hate-train, it was really disappointing. It has maybe 3 buildings you can walk into, and one of them is the Jarl's building, so that's just plain bad. Great Collapse happened in 4E122, that's 79 good years to rebuild. Riften was set on fire and burnt to the ground in 4E129, but the book Of Crossed Daggers says they rebuilt it to what we see in game in 5 years. No excuse, Winterhold. Your college is cool I guess, but even that was underwhelming

    (The same could I guess be said for Morthal or Falkreath, but at least they have cool side quests, like Laid to Rest and Ill Met by Moonlight. Those are fun. Winterhold is not)

    If you only include the big five, actually fleshed out and walled cities, then I guess I'd have to say, maybe... Whiterun? I think the big cities are all really good, I like the character each of them has. Markarth is scummy and rough, Riften is secretive and still kinda scummy, Windhelm is bleak and harsh, Solitude is all fancylike and bright. Whiterun I would say is the most bland or least stylized, but I still enjoy it quite a bit. I just spend the least amount of time there and I think it has some of the less interesting side quests? I don't know, I just end up around other cities more.

    • 441 posts
    December 6, 2017 12:49 AM EST
    Surprised to see so much Markarth because it's actually my favorite city. I also didn't expect to not see any Windhelm.
    • 1450 posts
    December 6, 2017 3:39 PM EST

    I think Riften? I'm going with Riften. It's in a nice hold, lots of history. Gorgeous scenery, a temple to Mara. Even multiple shrines to Dibella in the form of Haelga. It's just that I can't do anything with it. Thieves Guild or bust seems to be the options. So we have this Doom Driven force of change, the Hero of prophecy, like the only goddam person on the face of Tamriel who can change what is written... but simply making Riften a more upstanding little town is utterly beyond the character's capabilities.

    • 444 posts
    December 6, 2017 6:36 PM EST

    Paws said:

    ... but simply making Riften a more upstanding little town is utterly beyond the character's capabilities.

    Actually, a quest that allows you to shut down the Thieves Guild would be pretty boss! When you think about it, there really is a missed opportunity there, especially considering Mjoll's dialogue about sticking around to try to straighten Riften out. Seems like the natural progression for that town would be either to make the TG king, or do the opposite and shut the guild down entirely. Kind of a shame.

    • 1232 posts
    December 6, 2017 6:46 PM EST

    ShinJin said:

    Paws said:

    ... but simply making Riften a more upstanding little town is utterly beyond the character's capabilities.

    Actually, a quest that allows you to shut down the Thieves Guild would be pretty boss! When you think about it, there really is a missed opportunity there, especially considering Mjoll's dialogue about sticking around to try to straighten Riften out. Seems like the natural progression for that town would be either to make the TG king, or do the opposite and shut the guild down entirely. Kind of a shame.

    You can kill a good chunk of them

  • December 6, 2017 7:19 PM EST

    But uhh, my least favorite would have to be Dawnstar. I just...there's nothing about it that I enjoy really, Morthal has the cool atmosphere, Falkreath has the puns, Markarth, Solitude, and Whiterun are all fucking awesome cities, Winterhold at least looks unique and interesting and Riften is just kinda cool. Dawnstar...well it has a lighthouse I guess, but really I just don't care about it at all.

  • Meh
    • 112 posts
    December 6, 2017 7:57 PM EST

    I am going to change my answer after learning about what all the cities were like in Arena and even in Lore, I would have to say they are all pretty bad.

    • 68 posts
    December 10, 2017 7:51 PM EST
    My least favorite city is probably Markarth. I don’t like that you’re railroaded into Molag Bal’s nonsense and forced to kill a decent-seeming person. I don’t like the brutal class divide, I hate everything about the Silver-Bloods, and I’m also annoyed that the people of Markarth live in a city full of relics and only make token mention of the fact. They talk more about the Forsworn.
    This post was edited by Mercurias at December 10, 2017 8:00 PM EST